Books and their films

Want to recommend a wonderful book to other members? Please do so ... whether it's food or not, we'd love to find out more.

 
 
 

Page :  1
avatar
Elpe

Books and their films

Blondie's comment on the previous thread prompted me to ask whether you prefer to read the book first or see the film. For me, I much prefer to read the book first so I can form my own images of what the characters are like, imagine the settings and try to predict the plot or story line. Sometimes the film can be a bit of a let-down especially when they cut out loads or alter things eg the ending as happened in The Horse Whisperer though I didn't object to looking at Robert Redford - LOL!

Books and their films

I must say I very rarely watch a film that I have read the book to. It does always seem a let down particularly if say the whole ending has been changed. A few that spring to mind though would be the first Harry Potter film, I think because it was a short book they could keep most of the story in.

The Devil Wears Prada was a good film, Meryl Streep was fantastic.

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas was shot from a totally different perspective to the book, and with the music was, I thought, really good - gave me goosebumps!

avatar
SusanM

Book v Film

Whatever I do first I do not do the other cos it is bound to spoil it . Prefer reading to seeing though .

avatar
Liz from Cumbria

Definitely prefer reading

I'm guilty of nodding off when watching a film - even (maybe especially)in the cinema! Must be the dark that does it - well that's my excuse anyway.

avatar
JAMES

Book, every time!

Def the book. There are not many films that I really like. They bore me.

cannot sit down through an entire film in one go, I get too bored, yet I can easilly sit on the sofa reading for three hours in an evening! go figure!

XXX

avatar
lemonsqueaky

Books and Their Films

Both my sister and loved 'The Name of the Rose' as a film, then read the book. It was a million times better, so convoluted. The film I won't see is 'Life of Pi' because I have my own image of what happened (or didn't).

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

avatar
ChocTruffle

Book rather than film

I also much prefer to read a book first rather than see the film first. You are able to form your own ideas and opinions about characters and scenes and sometimes the film can spoil these.
I read "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas" and I'm afraid I can not bring myself to watch the film as I know the ending and do not want to face seeing it on a big screen!

avatar
sam from worthing

Book

all the way, I usually extremely dissappointed in film adaptations of books.

Hated Boy in Stripped Pyjamas on film. Hated Da Vinci Code on film.

However there is a couple of expceptions...

The god father films are amazing - the book i can never get on with. and also misery by stephen king - both book and film i thought were excellant.

There has been a few films out lately, that i didn;t realise were books originally, like the duchess for one - i would like to read that.

but on the whole prefer books to film versions.

 
Page :  1

Return to Homepage
Visit the Delia Online Cookery School with Waitrose
Click here to go to Waitrose.com

 

 




NetObserver
CMS solutions by REDtechnology.com